Forbes Editor Dismissed Over Undisclosed $6 Million Payment

The top editor of Forbes left his position last month, reportedly dismissed for accepting $6 million from the founder of a firm that does business with the magazine. The departure of Randall Lane, who served as editor and chief content officer, has raised serious questions about journalistic ethics and the integrity of business media.

What led to the editor's departure from Forbes?

The New York Times reported this week that Randall Lane was paid by RJ Shook, whose company, Shook Research, has worked with Forbes since 2016 to publish rankings of wealth advisers. The payment was made after Shook sold a majority stake in the company to a private equity firm a year ago.

An internal email dated July 23 and reviewed by The Associated Press confirmed that Lane no longer worked for the company. It provided no other details of his departure. Lane had worked for Forbes for nearly 16 years and as its top editor since 2017.

A person who works at Forbes and spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue told the AP that the staff discovered the apparent reasons behind the firing by reading the Times story. A subsequent email sent out this week said the company could not comment on the matter further.

What did the former editor say about the payment?

The Times quoted a person familiar with Lane's thinking as saying he considered the payment a gift in return for advice he had provided Shook over the years.

“I made a mistake, and I take responsibility for it. I should have disclosed the gift and failing to was a serious error in judgment. I deeply regret that, and I lost the job and team I love because of it,” Mr. Lane said in a statement to The Times.

Lane and a spokesperson for Forbes did not respond to requests for comment.

Why is this payment a breach of journalistic standards?

It remains unclear why Shook paid Lane. But the company and Forbes apparently had a close relationship. On its website, for example, Shook Research lists 12 rankings of wealth advisers and management teams in partnership with Forbes.

Also unclear is why Lane thought disclosing the payment would have solved the ethical issues it may have raised. Traditional newsrooms typically forbid journalists from accepting payments from sources or business partners to avoid conflicts of interest, or even the appearance of conflict.

Forbes' statement of editorial values and standards says that the company “prohibit(s) all staff members and contributors from accepting compensation, privileges or favors of any kind from people, companies or groups featured in their coverage.”

“Any real or perceived conflicts of interest or relationships at all (financial, professional, legal actions, personal or otherwise) must be avoided and/or discussed with the appropriate managing editor. If approved, it must be explicitly disclosed in the story to readers to maintain their trust,” it reads. “Any attempt to evade or failure to honor these solemn responsibilities is a serious offense and is subject to review and swift disciplinary action.”

How does this affect public trust in the media?

The Times report comes at a low moment for public trust in the media. A majority of Americans, 57%, said they have low confidence in journalists to act in the best interests of the public, according to a Pew Research Center analysis in February.

Forbes was founded in 1917 and developed into an influential biweekly account of corporate America, putting giants like Steve Jobs and Warren Buffett on its cover.

Lane was apparently aware of trust issues in the news business. In 2024, he published a column titled, “How Forbes Delivers Journalism You Can Trust.”

“Thomas Jefferson famously noted that we get the government we deserve. That's true of our media too,” he wrote.

Frequently asked questions about the Forbes editor controversy

Who is Randall Lane?

Randall Lane was the top editor and chief content officer at Forbes. He worked for the company for nearly 16 years and served as its top editor since 2017.

What is Shook Research?

Shook Research is a firm founded by RJ Shook that has worked with Forbes since 2016 to publish rankings of wealth advisers. The company sold a majority stake to a private equity firm a year ago.

What are Forbes' editorial standards regarding gifts?

Forbes prohibits all staff members and contributors from accepting compensation, privileges or favors of any kind from people, companies or groups featured in their coverage. Any conflicts of interest must be disclosed to readers.